Skip to content

By the organization of in-depth exchange meetings, the Collaborative Soy Initiative seeks to initiate a bridge building process between the different international and regional initiatives committed to the deforestation and conversion free sustainable soy agenda. The so-called Meta Meetings of Soy Initiatives have brought together key representatives of initiatives since 2020. The objective of these meetings has been to create more synergy & more consistency between different approaches & strategies, to explore how the initiatives can be more complementary and mutually reinforcing, and finally to identify the fields of intensive collaboration, by a process of collective thinking. It has led to a collective narrative and dialogue tool, the Magicube.

November 18th CSI Outreach webinar of Meta Meetings:

The multiple routes to sustainable sourcing, combining the best of approaches for conversion-free sustainable soy.  

There is no silver bullet in soy. How often do we hear this? But how do we combine the best of approaches to achieve to the best of results, and what are practical examples of this? An outreach webinar of our "Meta Meetings" between soy initiatives was held to communicate a shared Narrative and a provoking tool (the Soy Magicube) to inform policies of companies and governments alike. The art of combining: an eyeopener for our blind spots?

The Two pager

The Narrative

The Soy Magicube

The 18 nov presentation

The 18 nov recording

Participants of the Meta Meetings

These meetings have brought together the 15 most relevant initiatives with regional or global reach. The names of the participating initiatives and the coordinators can be downloaded here.  Disclaimer: this is the list when we started, it also has known changes over time.

The outcome of the closed Meta Meetings so far, 2020-2021

To start with, the participants were asked to prepare a one pager with general information & specific information regarding their contributions and encountered hurdles regarding deforestation free sustainable soy. This survey can be downloaded here.

Collectively, we identified 5 interrelated core actions for making scale and creating impact that could benefit from our collaboration in CSI:

1.     Promote ambitious, compatible sustainability targets by users to create scale for conversion free sustainable soy

2.     Based on these goals & targets create consistent (at least compatible) asks to traders and producers

3.     Develop a shared narrative of these asks

4.     Engage with traders and producers to create effective and constructive communication about asks

5.     Create incentives for producers to meet requirements

In the two 2020 Meta Meetings presentations were held on these topics:

Presentation: the Accountability Framework

Presentation: the Soy Transparency Coalition

Presentation: CGF Forest Positive Coalition of Action

Presentation: the Amsterdam Declaration Partnership and engagement

Presentation: ProTerra engagement activities and incentives for the producers

Presentation: PCI and RTRS working on incentives for producers

In March 2021 we specifically discussed dealing with requirements (asks) and incentives for suppliers in conversion risk landscapes, such as the Cerrado. How can asks, such as legal and conversion-free responsible soy production and increased transparency in the value chain, be better matched by incentives, such as market access, preferential sourcing, and financial incentives such as premiums and payments for ecosystem services? Work in progress for collective thinking.

In June 2021 we followed up on these issues and discussed the convergence and collective elements of a shared (CSI) narrative that we've been able to create sofar. Meanwhile we encounter confusion in the market. "Conversion free physical soy now!" is of high importance, but are we losing the recognition of integrated criteria (beyond conversion  free) and the down-to-the-ground lessons from landscape initiatives? What do such different instruments have to offer in terms of solutions, and what do combinations of them deliver?

We need to combine the multiple roads to a responsible Rome. We presented a draft "magicube" for soy sustainability solutions, to be used in different combinations for different circumstances. Furthermore we've learnt more about what the Soy Roadmap and Soy Toolkit have to offer as guidance on supplier engagement specifically.  See powerpoint presentation with combined contributions from Heleen van den Hombergh, CSI and Jane Lino & Sylvia Torres Castro, Proforest

Presentation 5th CSI Meta Meeting, CSI & Proforest

And last not least, we learnt about the new PES mechanism for soy being piloted in the Brazilian Cerrado right now, by Fabiola Zerbini, Tropical Forest Alliance. 

TFA on PSA Soy Brazil for CSI Meta Meeting

In September 2021 we internally discussed a shared narrative and dialogue tool.

On November 18th an open access outreach webinar was held on our shared narrative, a thought-provoking tool and lessons learnt on the Multiple Routes to Responsibility.  See above!

For more information write to